I can’t help but come back to the conversations I imagine between the two nineteenth-century theologians—Andrew Murray, the South African pastor and author, and Hannah Whitall Smith, author of The Christian’s Secret of a Happy Life. Both have been gone for more than a century, but their books keep getting into conversations in my head.
This time, they are considering prayer that is simultaneously to be without ceasing, and without anxiety.
The prayer meeting had ended, and the others had gone. In the little study where they had gathered, Andrew drew an armchair closer to the fire and sat down, warming his hands. Hannah moved towards the door while pulling on her glove.
“Will you stay a little longer?” he asked. “I thought we might pray for the sisters again.”
Hannah paused, searching her coat pocket. “I think I’ve said everything I came to say.”
“For tonight, you mean?”
“I guess I meant for tonight when I said it, but now that you ask, I don’t know why I should promise to say it again tomorrow. I’ve put them in God’s hands. I meant that when I said it.”
Her search produced a wrapped peppermint. She set it beside the Bible on the little table and reached into her pocket again.
Andrew looked at her quizzically and said, “Must you stop asking for their reconciliation to prove that you’ve entrusted them to him?”
“Must I keep asking to prove that I haven’t forgotten them?”
Andrew smiled and said, “The persistent widow might have something to say about that. She went back to the judge multiple times until he finally gave her justice.”
“But that widow had to persuade someone who cared nothing for her,” Hannah said. “I’ve been speaking to someone who loves those women more than either of us does. Surely that gives me some reason to go home believing they’re fully cared for.”
“I believe in that care, as well,” Andrew said. “But why should that bring my asking to an end?”
“Because we often leave our prayers looking as though we’ve been trying to persuade someone who would rather be rid of us?” replied Hannah.
“That’s only because we understand him so poorly, but spending time with him ought to help us with that. Doesn’t knowing how great His love is for them give me every reason to continue to ask for their reconciliation? I can trust him with them and still believe he means to accomplish something through my continued prayers.”
Hannah found her glove and shook it out. “Yes, though going home while nothing has changed can require a good deal of trust, too.”
“It can,” Andrew agreed. “But staying can require that same trust. When the answer is delayed, and we keep company with God without the encouragement of having received what we asked for, we discover how much we want the blessing for another person, and how much time we’re willing to give to seeking it. What’s more, as we continue, God has the opportunity to deepen the very trust we came with. I believe there’s something to be learned in returning when we have nothing new to report.”
“And something to be learned in leaving when nothing has changed,” Hannah added. “Suppose I gave you a property, properly and entirely, and then came back tomorrow to give it to you again. And the next day, and the next, because I couldn’t quite believe you’d accepted it. After a month of this, you would start to wonder whether I ever meant you to have it.”
“I should begin to wonder whether you still considered it yours.”
“Exactly. Every time I came back to give it to you again, I’d be treating it as though it were still mine to give. But with God, we can go on for years, offering ourselves to him and then wondering whether he’s taken us up on the offering. We ask him to take us in hand, then search our feelings to discover whether he has. At some point, we have to believe the transaction is real, Andrew. We can leave his presence with something settled, even while there is a great deal still to happen.”
Andrew rested his hands on the arms of his chair. “Yes. But I’m asking those women to be reconciled. And though I’m quite persuaded God has heard me, I believe he can use my next prayer as well as my last.”
Hannah glanced at his Bible and then back at him. “Tell me what you mean by that.”
“A farmer doesn’t regard yesterday’s sowing as a reason to leave today’s seed in the sack. Each part of the work belongs to the harvest. I believe our prayers have that kind of consequence. There may be things in us, or in others, that must be put right before the answer comes. We can’t see all that God is doing through our asking.”
“And in the meantime, what becomes of our rest?”
“Must you suppose I’m restless because I’m still here?”
That earned him a smile.
“No. But you must allow that a person can pray very earnestly while scarcely believing God can be trusted with the matter. She thinks she ought to be anxious about those she loves. An afternoon without worrying almost seems a failure of affection. I should like her to discover that God’s care continues even when she has stopped thinking about it.”
“So should I. But suppose she stops asking because she no longer expects God to answer. She says she’s left it with him, when she has just gotten tired of being disappointed. How does she know she’s accepting his will? Has he made it known to her, or has she just decided that because he hasn’t answered yet, he never will?”
“I would ask her whether she knows how good his will is,” Hannah said. “People speak of yielding to God as though they have to prepare themselves for the worst he can do. A mother imagines that if she gives him her child, she has supplied him with an opportunity to make her life miserable. But if her child entrusted himself to her like that, she would gather him into her arms. Does she suppose herself more loving than God?”
“That means she has every reason to come to him.”
“And every reason to leave the child with him when she goes.”
Andrew nodded, though his arms remained crossed.
From the passage came the sound of cups being gathered onto a tray. Hannah moved aside as their hostess appeared in the doorway and reached for the two remaining on the table. When she had gone, Andrew spoke again.
“I know you want those sisters reconciled.”
“Very much.”
“Then you understand why I’m staying. I’ve no power to soften either heart. But I have a Friend to whom I can bring their need. I can ask him for what I haven’t got to give them. And their need might just require more of my time than I had intended to spend.”
“Yes, provided you let him direct you in the matter. Don’t be like the patient who asked the physician to take charge of his case, then insisted on choosing which instructions he would follow. Don’t give God charge, then reserve your right to arrange the treatment.”
“Indeed,” Andrew said, leaning forward. “And if I do discover, while praying, that I’ve been trying to arrange the treatment myself, I will give that up to him, too. You’re right that he must have the whole case. But I may need time in his company to discover how much of it I’m still keeping in my own hands.”
Hannah looked at him for a moment.
“Yes,” she said as she turned towards the door. “I can accept that. Provided we believe he has undertaken the case before we have understood the whole treatment.”
“I believe he has,” Andrew said. “And I trust him to show me what comes next.”
Hannah turned to look at him from the doorway. “Then I shall leave you to your consultation.”
Andrew laughed and reached for his Bible.
“You’re quite determined to go,” he said.
“I was ready before you asked me to stay. You’ve kept me here considerably longer than I intended.”
“Perhaps you’ll forgive me.”
“I expect so. Though I shall entrust the timing to the Lord.”
She pulled on her second glove and remembered the peppermint and nearly went back for it. Then she decided Andrew could have it.
He was still in the armchair when she left, his Bible open beside the small, unopened sweet.
For more on prayer, surrender, and trust, see:
Hannah Whitall Smith, The Christian’s Secret of a Happy Life—especially “The Life Defined,” “How to Enter In,” and “Difficulties Concerning Consecration.”
Andrew Murray, With Christ in the School of Prayer—especially “The Boldness of God’s Friends” and “The Power of Persevering Prayer.”
This imagined conversation draws on their writings. The dialogue and setting are fictional.




What a conversation. I love Andrew and Hannah’s writings. Thank you, I will think about this a lot today.😊